3. Stakeholder Consultation
The Study Team have spoken with the Rail Passengers' Committee for Southern
England who consider that the railway on the Island should be developed and
expanded and supplied papers from the conference held earlier this year in Ryde
arranged by the R.P.C. to consider the future of the railway on the Isle of
Wight.
The IoW Council arranged an opportunity for the Study Team to
meet with various user and interest groups, which augmented the record of their
input at the Conference. These bodies included Wight Track, IoW Transport 2000,
Ventnor Railway Association and the Isle of Wight Tramway. Although the views
of these four bodies differed somewhat in the detail of suggested route
alignments and priorities for expansion of the rail system on the Island, there
was consensus on a number of key factors:
• the essential
requirement to retain the existing Island Line;
• the significant
potential non-financial benefit that rail expansion may
bring;
• that light rail might bring significant advantage compared
with conventional 'heavy rail' solutions including the ability to bypass
encroachments on former rail trackbed, together with the possibility of a
greater ability to penetrate town centres;
• that joint running
with the IoW Steam Railway between Smallbrook and Wootton could be difficult but
might be feasible;
• that priorities for rail expansion should
include linking Newport, Cowes and Ventnor with Ryde and each other.
The
Study Team have met with senior representatives at the IoW Steam Railway. The
IoW Steam Railway is a registered educational charity that provides a tourist
attraction through recreating the atmosphere of the pre-nationalisation steam
railway and this is reflected in the infrastructure and rolling stock used on
the line. The railway is operated and maintained largely by a volunteer
workforce although there are some paid staff and some work is undertaken by
outside contractors. During helpful discussions, the following was established
with the IOW Steam Railway:
• There is an aspiration to extend
steam train operations beyond Wootton although this is recognised as requiring
significant infrastructure works.
• They would be willing to
consider the development of a diesel passenger service over their route in
addition to existing steam train operations.
• Electrification
between Smallbrook and Wootton would probably be impractical on aesthetic and
safety grounds, and would be unlikely to gain HMRI approval.
• A
track access charge could be levied by the Steam Railway to cover their
additional infrastructure maintenance and operating cost for the services.
They could potentially make use of an extension into Newport for steam
trains, if a suitable locomotive run round facility were provided. Seam trains
would continue to terminate at Smallbrook, unless Island Line was ever to vacate
one of the running lines to Ryde St John's Road